David Maddox: Currying favour at Christmas
The idea that Christmas parties reflect the fortunes of their hosts seems to be confirmed with a comparison between this year and last year of the bashes arranged by Scotland's leading political rivals - SNP First Minister Alex Salmond and Labour's Scottish Secretary Jim Murphy.Last year, despite the SNP losing heavily to Labour in the Glenrothes by-election, Mr Salmond still gave the impression he could turn water into wine or at least walk on water, while Labour appeared to be stuck in the doldrums.
So the 2008 Christmas party arranged by Mr Salmond for Scottish political hacks involved top notch award winning curry, lots of drinks and a long reception at Bute House, the First Minister's official residence.
Meanwhile Mr Murphy's staff forgot to send invitations to the media for an event which involved a few drinks and crisps and was lumped together with inviting various parts of Scotland's great and good.
How different it is this year. Last Thursday Mr Murphy entertained the political hacks with curry and drinks, including Scotland's strongest beer (since Brewdog's Tokyo was banned), at 7.8 per cent, perhaps symbolic of Labour's decision to torpedo the SNP's minimum pricing for booze policy. Overall the event, as did the host's demeanour, reflected a far more confident relaxed attitude encouraged by rising political fortunes.
Labour of course have just thumped the SNP in Glasgow North East while Mr Salmond appears to be struggling with the SNP behind in the polls and having no chance of getting its referendum. There is also the small matter of the education crisis which led to the sacking of Fiona Hyslop from the cabinet.
Which brings us on to Mr Salmond's hastily arranged Christmas do for the media this year. This afternoon we learnt that it has now been diaried at the Scottish Government offices in St Andrew's House for a few drinks for Thursday, the busiest day in parliament, for an hour and 15 minutes at 5.45pm, a time when most journalists are stuck on deadlines and unable to attend.
Mr Salmond's office said this was because the original date clashed with the Tartan Bollocks (The Scottish Parliament Journalist Association's annual dinner named after the award for the worst story of the year -NB this is not the story which cybernats most disapprove of).
But, many have seen this last minute arrangement as a reflection of the First Minister's waning fortunes. It certainly suggests he may be less happy than he was spending his time with journalists and that he is not exactly pleased with the coverage he is getting currently.
Of course the irony, if this is true, is that a party on the down would have more cause to try to get in the press's good books to get back into favour, but it seems that's not how politics, at least in Scotland, works.
Labels: Alex Salmond, Christmas Party, curry, David Maddox, Jim Murphy









12 Comments:
David,
"Tartan Bollocks" - a bit infra dig to introduce mention of certain private parts of the anatomy on a blog. Whatever will those who peruse the blogs looking for naughty words make of it?
As a wee free I am shocked and horrified beyond measure!!
Quite a bit of irony in your last paragraph in view of daily attacks by your esteemed organ on the SNP.
Goodness, You've got me at it now.
Brownlie,
In the interests of accuracy I had to give the SPJA dinner its formal name.
If it is any comfort to you, Alex Salmond has named this infamous event at least twice at official functions I was attending, and once at a press conference.
David M
David, is your visceral dislike of the SNP/Salmond something you brought with you from Portsmouth, or is just something that you've developed since arriving here ? You really do write some very very sour stuff these days. "Politics and whine" on the main page ? Look in the mirror sir, that's you that is ... whining when Mike Russell didn't pay your 4th estate enough respect a few days ago ... now your whining because Salmond is rushing your freebie drinks before slamming the door behind your mob as you leave.
And no I'm not a party member. Just another former Scotsman buyer who wouldn't contemplate handing over my hard-earned cash to pay to read it any more.
David,
I, along with the majority of Scots, hold Salmond in high regard as a politician - not as a saint who cannot do anything wrong. After all, he is a Hearts supporter.
Maddox I'm sure your never happier than when sitting on Jim Murphy's knee sipping muld wine together!
Two points
1) Do you really expect us to believe that better access to Alex Salmond would result in better press coverage from you !
2) I think you vainly and arrogantly overstate the role of the print media in Scotland (have you checked the Scotsman's circulation figures lately !) . The Scotsman and the Daily Record both pleaded with the voters to vote Labour at the last election and look what happened (1 seat yes but a 20% swing)
3) The SNP are not on the way down the most recent Mori poll puts them above Labour again !
Surely as both of these events are funded by the taxpayer Scotsman journalists will be staying away?
I take it the Scotsman photgrapher didn't get an invite to Jim Murphy's curry bash. It's a bit cheap to use the same photo twice on The Steamie.
And David, did you actually get an invite to the Bute House party? In the spirit of Simon Cowell analogies, that would be like Rupert Murdoch getting an invite to 'Respect's' Christmas do...
Only joking, I'm sure anti-SNP hacks are looked after and treated as well as fair-minded ones.
This post has been removed by the author.
brownlie,
more than one journo caalls it that, as do most msps
by my reckoning angus macleod has won it 2 or 3 years running, last year i think for his "wendy, the fightback starts here story"
Holyrood Patter,
I'm well aware of that! I was only pulling my chum David's leg!
excellent, now the plot is to get tickets to this prestigous event, if only to watch messr macleod bring home the bacon.
although i hear kevin schofield is in with a shout this year
excellent, now the plot is to get tickets to this prestigous event, if only to watch messr macleod bring home the bacon.
although i hear kevin schofield is in with a shout this year
Post a Comment
<< Home