The Steamie

Monday, 13 July 2009

David Maddox: Fielding at silly point

There are two things you can count on in the summer months - cricket and the newspapers' silly season.
And, as seems to happen most years when there is an Ashes series, the SNP have managed to combine the two.
This time Sandra White (pictured top left), a Glasgow list MSP, has put down a motion calling on cricket to be removed from terrestrial television north of the Border because there is little interest for it here. Strange she should make the complaint considering that it only appears on news bulletins as Sky holds the rights to the game.
But even a cursory look at the evidence shows that she is wrong about cricket not being widely followed in Scotland.
There are 160 clubs registered with Cricket Scotland (including the Grange in Edinburgh, pictured right). Around 28,000 Scots play the sport, not least the Scotsman's own team, and thousands more support it. Some argue it is more played and better supported even than rugby and you never hear the Nationalists wanting to ban that sport from the television.
Scotland has also had some success competing against first class county teams in one day competitions and on the international stage. They have gained full international status in the one day game and got to the semi-finals of the 2005 ICC Trophy.
There have also been some notable Scottish players. Two of the current Scottish team play for first class counties Navdeep Poonia for Warwickshire and Kyle Coetzer for Durham.
My favourite is arguably England's greatest captain Douglas Jardine (pictured left), inventor of the infamous Bodyline bowling attack to tackle Don Bradman in the 1932/33 Ashes series. His name still still brings up the bristles on the Antipodean back.
Then there was the famous win in 2007 of Freuchie in the National Village Cricket Championships at Lords.
The sport has a long history here in Scotland too with the oldest club Kelso dating back to 1820.
Ms White of course is following in the footsteps of her fellow list SNP MSP Christine Grahame, who complained about the Ashes being on TV too much in 2005. Notably, she is yet to win a constituency contest in the Borders where cricket is most popular in Scotland, despite trying in a marginal seat three times which was one of the SNP's top targets in 2007.
It could be argued that the Nationalist dislike for the summer game comes from its historical sentiment over its origins in Scotland. It was first played by English soldiers stationed in Scotland in 1785 after they had put down the Jacobite rebellion along with Scottish Hanoverian soldiers at Culloden.
But one has to ask, as some political parties already have, whether having a go at cricket is a convenient way of having a go at the English without actually saying so as it is clear they consider the game to be an English one. It is certainly an easy way of trying to stir up anger over English interests being put over Scottish ones in television coverage.

Labels: , , , , ,

8 Comments:

Blogger Wardog said...

Haven't the SNP got better things to be getting on with rather than this nonsense.

Fair enough the BBC's dropping Scotland's Football matches was a diabolical decision but not need to take it out on cricket.

13 July 2009 21:09  
Blogger Wardog said...

I have to say David, how come when one SNP member puts down a bill you tarnish the whole party but when it's another MSP from another party who don't seem to do that.

Are you applying different standards.

Where is the discussion about Paul Martin's NHS (Scotland) Bilnot being supported by the Labour Party?

13 July 2009 21:11  
Blogger Scottish Unionist said...

Wardog:

Sandra White isn't the only culprit. Christine Grahame, Roseanna Cunningham, Bill Wilson and Bruce McFee have all pitched in with similar objections to cricket.

13 July 2009 22:39  
Blogger ScottishUnionism said...

Roseanne Cunnignham made a joke about the revialy between the teams, hardly a hanging offence AM@

"That the Parliament congratulates the England cricket side on their success in regaining the Ashes from Australia; notes that Australian generosity will not begrudge them a win once in 18 years, but expresses every confidence that Australia will regain the Ashes at the next meeting between the two countries."

Your trying a bit hard here.

Christine Grahame 's comment is quite right, when looked at in context (something you faield to do in your blog)

"That the Parliament notes the recent cricket win by England over Australia and, while congratulating England’s players, laments the overwhelming UK-wide coverage of a sport that is of only marginal interest in Scotland and further laments that England’s win is apparently of more importance than the continuing starvation of millions in Niger, the complete failure of the UK Government to deliver on the G8 promises and the continuing chaos in Iraq and Afghanistan, and notes that it provides a timely diversion from these desperate failures of the UK Government but that many of us are keeping our eye on another ball."

I find Sandra White's and Bill Wilson's comments needless and dismiss them out of hand for being a foolish waste of time, recess silliness.

Roddy Smith, chief executive of Cricket Scotland, has the right idea when he dismissed Ms White's motion as a "storm in a teacup" ......

Personally I detest cricket AND tennis.

I'm not sure what these two are complaining about, we've had days of glorious coverage of the Scottish Open at Loch Lomond on terrestrial TV.

14 July 2009 00:41  
Blogger Mighty said...

Remember that Roseanna Cunningham lived in Australia during her formative years too.

But if this is such a daft silly-season non-story, why is the scotsman covering it at all?

14 July 2009 11:33  
Blogger brownlie said...

Stuff and nonsense from these politicians. Have they not got anything better to spend their time on like ironing and cooking supper for their partners.

The last hour of the first test was one of the most exciting spectacles I've ever seen. It nearly convinced me to join the Barmy Army.

14 July 2009 20:54  
Blogger Administrator said...

Brownlie, if you do I might even buy you a trumpet to play the Australian national anthem on Barmy Army style... God Save the Queen.

15 July 2009 00:10  
Blogger brownlie said...

David,

I know the words of the Barmy Army song - the words of the anthem are beyond my intellectual capacity.

18 July 2009 09:29  

Post a Comment

<< Home